Math, History and Psychology – Part 2

William Smead
Chief Executive Officer
Chief Investment Officer

Dear Fellow Investors:

Last week we wrote about the math of common stock investing and the effectiveness of mathematical discipline to portfolio management. This week we will focus on history and the importance of that academic discipline to us as common stock portfolio managers here at Smead Capital Management (SCM).

Edmund Burke said, โ€œThose who donโ€™t know history are doomed to repeat it.โ€ We at SCM like to think in terms of taking advantage of what we know about history to make money owning good quality common stocks. Mark Twain said, โ€œHistory doesnโ€™t repeat itself, but it does rhyme!โ€ We believe these are the most important statements on how history should affect portfolio management decisions. In our opinion, you must know the history of the markets and you must trust the โ€œrhymesโ€ to be effective and successful.

We will use some historical examples to back up Burke and Twainโ€™s argument. History shows that there have been regular bouts of financial euphoria. In his book, โ€œA Short History of Financial Euphoriaโ€, John Kenneth Galbraith used the Tulip Mania of the 17th century and the โ€œSouth Sea Bubbleโ€ of the 18th century to help people understand how dangerous excessive optimism is in business. The aftermath of these speculative episodes was drastic and debilitating losses. Here is how Galbraith described the lead up into the height of the euphoria:

โ€œThe price of the object of speculation goes up. Securities, land, objects dโ€™art, and other property, when bought today are worth more tomorrow. This increase and the prospect attract new buyers; the new buyers assure a further increase. Yet more are attracted; yet buy; the increase continues. The speculation building on itself provides its own momentum.

This process, once it is recognized, is clearly evident, and especially so after the fact. So also, if more subjectively, are the basic attitudes of the participants. These take two forms. There are those who are persuaded that some new price-enhancing circumstance is in control, and they expect the market to stay up and go up, perhaps indefinitely. It is adjusting to a new situation, a new world of greatly, even infinitely increasing returns and resulting values. Then there are those, superficially more astute and generally fewer in number, who perceive or believe themselves to perceive the speculative mood of the moment. They are in to ride the upward wave; their particular genius, they are convinced, will allow them to get out before the speculation runs its course. They will get the maximum reward from the increase as it continues; they will be out before the eventual fall.โ€

History shows that these speculative episodes will happen and those who know history are to avoid participation in these episodes. It was tulips in the Netherlands, common stock in the South Seas, Western Railroads in the 1860โ€™s and 1870โ€™s, technology like cars, planes and radios in the 1920โ€™s, the internet in the late 1990โ€™s and residential real estate in 2005. We believe you must understand and know the history of these events and avoid participation in them once they get speculative!

Folks have wondered why we believe that Chinaโ€™s economy and their miraculous last thirty years of economic growth arenโ€™t sustainable. The answer is simple. CHINA HAS ALREADY QUALIFIED AS THE BENEFICIARY OF A SPECULATIVE EPISODE. THIS KIND OF UNINTERRUPTED ECONOMIC SUCCESS HAS ALWAYS ENDED BADLY IN ALL RECORDED ECONOMIC HISTORY! China has not had an economic contraction in thirty years.ย  As Galbraith pointed out, China is in a new world of greatly, even infinitely increasing returns and resulting values. In China, itโ€™s all about GDP growth, because their internal stock market broke down four years ago and even that has not stopped the euphoria associated with Chinaโ€™s future. The speculative episode just moved to houses from stocks in China.

The most successful economy of all time, the US economy, grew 9% compounded from 1800 to 1900. However, there were 18 recessions, 3 depressions and 3 all-out panics. The economy was cleansed of its sins by regular economic contractions. As Warren Buffett says, โ€œOnly when the tide goes out do you discover who is swimming naked.โ€ In China, the tide has never been allowed to go out. Bad loans, fraud and poor investments have never been exposed and the masses have not been forced to learn and improve their economic behavior.

This is why Twainโ€™s quote about history rhyming is so important. Every time that one of these episodes comes along, investors and professional portfolio managers focus on the difference in the current episode to the past ones. History repeats itself, but not identically! Therefore, the temptation is to focus on the difference and repeat the mistakes. This is true at both positive and negative extremes. A few examples might be helpful.

We were in a deep recession with as high as 10.8% unemployment in 1981-82. Incredibly high interest rates crippled the economy and smokestack America. Budget deficits were high and the US national debt grew immensely. Stocks were out of favor and 1981-82 was a great time to buy many good quality common stocks.

Along came the meltdown of 2007-2009, with a deep recession which included 10% unemployment. Very few professional investors were buyers or holders of good quality common stocks back in late 2008 or early 2009. The 2009 market bottom was triggered by too much debt and the massive deleveraging which has occurred since then. Everyone told us not to buy because, โ€œItโ€™s different this time.โ€ In 1981-82 it was the price of money which crippled the economy and in 2009 it was the huge principle balances which crippled it.

Fortunately for us and unfortunately for those who couldnโ€™t sense the rhyme, 2009 was a great time to buy good quality US common stocks. Those who focused on the differences and ignored the rhyme missed the entire comeback the stock market has made since March of 2009. It grieves us to see the massive amount of capital which resides in doomsday-oriented mutual funds and ETFs, whose path to success would be our countryโ€™s failure to make a full comeback in this deleveraging process. So far, the optimists have outperformed and the 1982 playbook proved to be effective.

We believe the latest history to trust is the rhyme between the US economy and stock market in 1952 and today. In both cases, the US economy had high unemployment, huge government debt, massive recent stimulus, the Federal Reserve Board capping long-term interest rates, historically high profits as a percentage of GDP and what we believe are cheap large-cap stocks. Back then we funded the Marshall Plan to help Europe and Japan, as well as the GI Bill. Today, it is enormous unemployment compensation and deficit spending. Despite all those headwinds and a reversion to the mean in corporate profits as a percentage of GDP, the Dow Jones Industrial Average rose from 260 in 1952 to near 1000 in 1966. Those who ignored the headwinds created wealth and those who sat on the sidelines or hoped to make money from the misery of others ended up poorer. Will those circumstances play out differently this time? Or will this situation rhyme with 1952? At SCM, we are paid to trust the rhymes!

Here is how Galbraith concluded his thesis on the history of euphoria:

โ€œAt the risk of repetitionโ€”restatement of what one hopes is now evidentโ€”let the lessons be summarized. The circumstances that induce the recurrent lapses into financial dementia have not changed in any truly operative fashion since the Tulip Mania of 1636-37. Individuals and institutions are captured by the wondrous satisfaction from accruing wealth. The associated illusion of insight is protected, in turn by the oft-noted public impression that intelligence, oneโ€™s own and that of others, marches in close step with the possession of money. Out of that belief, thus instilled, then comes actionโ€”the bidding up of values, whether in land, securities, or, as recently, art. The upward movement confirms the commitment to personal and group wisdom. And so on to the moment of mass disillusion and the crash. This last, it will now be sufficiently evident, never comes gently. It is always accompanied by a desperate and largely unsuccessful effort to get out.โ€

Next week we will talk about psychology.

Best Wishes,

William Smead

The information contained in this missive represents SCM’s opinions, and should not be construed as personalized or individualized investment advice. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All of the securities identified and described in this missive are a sample of issuers being currently recommended for suitable clients as of the date stated in this missive and do not represent all of the securities purchased or recommended for our clients. It should not be assumed that investing in these securities was or will be profitable. A list of all recommendations made by Smead Capital Management within the past twelve month period is available upon request.

We Advise Investors

Sign up to get our advice sent straight to your inbox.

Recent Missives

Thankful For James Chanos

November 21, 2023

[...] Even though we are eternal optimists by nature as long-only value managers, we relished Jim's thoughts and studied his logic. He attempted to do on the short side what we try to...

โŸถ Keep Reading

Reuters: Cole Smead, CFA on Canada Goose’s Chinese Business

November 1, 2023

Estee Lauder, Canada Goose slash annual targets as China recovery drags By Ananya Mariam Rajesh and Aatrayee Chatterjee For more information go to reuters.com. Stocks mentioned: GOOS The information contained … Reuters: Cole...

โŸถ Keep Reading

Reuters: Bill Smead on Amgen

October 31, 2023

Amgen sales rise, but shares off as investors await obesity data By Deena Beasley For more information go to reuters.com. Stocks mentioned: AMGN The information contained in this tv appearance … Reuters: Bill...

โŸถ Keep Reading

Artificial (Stock Market) Life Support

October 31, 2023

[...] In The Godfather movie, peace didnโ€™t last long. Michael Corleone took over from his father and proceeded to murder the leaders of the other mafia families in the New York area. The...

โŸถ Keep Reading

Granthamโ€™s Contradictions

October 24, 2023

[...] Let me also start this missive by saying that we at Smead Capital Management believe Jeremy Grantham is doing a great job of telling people how high the likelihood of stock market...

โŸถ Keep Reading

Bloomberg: Cole Smead, CFA on US Energy Stocks

October 23, 2023

US Oil Dealmaking at Full Tilt as Chevron Agrees to Buy Hess By David Wethe, Kevin Crowley, Mitchell Ferman, and Kiel Porter For more information go to www.bloomberg.com. Stocks mentioned: … Bloomberg: Cole...

โŸถ Keep Reading

We Advise Investors

Sign up to get our advice sent straight to your inbox.

US INVESTORS

Individual Investors

OR

Financial Advisors, Family Offices,
and Institutional Investors

OR

NON-US INVESTORS

Individual Investors

OR

Financial Advisors, Family Offices,
and Institutional Investors

OR

Scroll to Top