Stock Investors in Barbieland

Printable Version

Dear fellow investors, 

The Barbie movie has been a $1 billion blockbuster movie so far in 2023. While it is entertaining like a Mel Brooks-style comedy, it also leaves you to ask: What is the real world? (Spoiler alert) Barbie is living in Barbieland where everything is perfect for Barbie and the other Barbies. It is in essence a feminist utopia where the men, known as the Kens, are glorified male models.

Barbie has an existential crisis when she has thoughts of death and walks flat-footed, instead of her heels floating six inches above her toes. She goes to the real world to solve her problem, where she learns reality is messy with no simple answer. She learns it’s a complex system. To not ruin the movie, I’ll briefly say she rejects Barbieland in the end and wants to make her way in the real world. A stunning outcome from the supposedly perfect world where she started.

Stock investors seem to have an idyllic view just as Barbie had. They had thoughts of death during the violent, but quick, bear market in the spring of 2020. They also learned that six-inch heels didn’t work for many formerly glamorous businesses as the declines in 2022 brought them back to the ground. Barbie was a pragmatist, though, and sought to get a check-up with her gynecologist at the end of the movie. Stock investors seem uninterested in finding out what is going on.

For most of my career, short-term rates have been laughable. No different than cowboys eating baked beans around a western movie campfire. However, the 90-day Treasury today pays 5.50%, a historically high rate. There is nothing laughable about that fact. It is an incredible risk-free return with great flexibility in relation to future inflation.

Ben Graham taught all investors that prevailing interest rates do affect what an informed investor should pay for the net present value of the future income stream. He used the current AAA corporate bond yield to adjust for this. If you can make risk-free 5.5%, what should you expect out of your corporate bonds, and therefore, how should you value stocks based on those rates? Below is a chart that helps us understand where things are.

The chart above shows the short-term money market yield against the S&P 500 Index’s price-to-earnings ratio (P/E) and price-to-book ratio (P/B). When rates dove to the floor, it makes sense that these metrics found new highs. What doesn’t make sense is that they are not that far off their high when adjusted for interest rates.

In the Ben Graham model, he viewed 4.4% to be the long-term rate to adjust the prevailing AAA corporate bond yield against. A 1% higher rate for valuing a business would cause a 23% change in the price that you’d pay for the stock. What is hard to perfectly ascertain is what the actual discounting mechanism is, but when you see short-term rates move over 500 bps, something should markedly change in how investors value assets. To believe that the value of the S&P 500 has only changed by 35% based on the drop in P/E ratios or a 15% drop in P/B ratios after this tectonic rise leads you to believe that stock investors are just another Ken in Barbieland. After all, it’s a fantasy land.

Our CIO, Bill Smead, explained in his recent missive, Inflation Expectations, how interesting the 30-year TIPs yield is right now. It provides a real rate of 2%. So, the question for investors is what will inflation be and how will it affect stocks? We believe it’s like asking what happens when gravity shows up. In Barbieland no one gets hurt. The real world is different.

Focusing more on the stock situation, above is the chart of the AAA corporate bond yield. During the peak multiples of 2021, I would say it averaged somewhere closer to 3%. Today, it yields almost 5%. The market consensus view is that we are going back to 3% inflation. If you add the 2% TIPs yield to that, you are way up with the current rate of the AAA corporate bond yield. A 2% change from the high point of valuations would cause roughly a 45% decline in the hypothetical P/E multiple you would value a stock. If inflation doesn’t run at 3%, but instead runs at 4% or 5%, it only gets worse! The higher nominal rates that inflation may cause are not being considered by stock investors in valuing individual businesses or the stock market at large.

The stocks for the long run crowd would argue that stocks benefit from inflation in a way that bonds don’t, but the reality is that everything (prices in relation to earnings and book value) gets worse with higher inflation.

Investors should fear death like Barbie did. We call it stock market failure. These valuations won’t go up like a six-inch heel. Flats may be more fitting for thinking about stock returns going forward. The only way to fight this for stock investors is to be scrutinous about the businesses you own and what you are paying for those stocks. In the Barbie movie, Ken wandered the real world trying to make sense of things. He only came to bad conclusions and never ended up with Barbie. Stock investors could be no different in their own fantasy land.

Fear stock market failure,

Cole Smead, CFA

The information contained in this missive represents Smead Capital Management’s opinions, and should not be construed as personalized or individualized investment advice and are subject to change. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Cole Smead, CFA, CEO and Portfolio Manager, wrote this article. It should not be assumed that investing in any securities mentioned above will or will not be profitable. Portfolio composition is subject to change at any time and references to specific securities, industries and sectors in this letter are not recommendations to purchase or sell any particular security. Current and future portfolio holdings are subject to risk. In preparing this document, SCM has relied upon and assumed, without independent verification, the accuracy and completeness of all information available from public sources. A list of all recommendations made by Smead Capital Management within the past twelve-month period is available upon request.

©2023 Smead Capital Management, Inc. All rights reserved.

This Missive and others are available at www.smeadcap.com.

We Advise Investors

Sign up to get our advice sent straight to your inbox.

Recent Missives

2Q24 U.S. Value Strategy Newsletter: Avoiding the Crowd

July 15, 2024

The Federal Reserve Board reported its most recent Z-1 on household assets. It revealed that households directly own 27% of their assets in common stock and indirectly own 13% through funds/ETFs/401ks. They also...

⟶ Keep Reading

2Q24 International Value Strategy Newsletter: Our Edge

July 15, 2024

As the investors of the strategy look back at the first half of 2024, we believe it is important to understand where we sit and what our edge as investors is. With the...

⟶ Keep Reading

Cantillon Marries the Red Queen

July 9, 2024

[...] Cycles are an inescapable attribute of markets just as in nature. Cantillon’s theory helps further illuminate how these cycles are created and behave within economies. It also explains why we find oil...

⟶ Keep Reading

Two Plus Two Still Equals Four

July 2, 2024

We are contrarians and oddly crave the moments when history, psychology and mathematics get defied in the U.S. stock market. We believe this is one of those points in time. [...]

⟶ Keep Reading

Cole Smead, CFA at the 2024 London Value Investor Conference

June 19, 2024

Cole Smead, CFA presented “Fossilized Value in a Crazy World” at the 2024 London Value Investor Conference For more information go to www.valueinvest.com. The information contained in this article represents […]

⟶ Keep Reading

The Genesis of Our Stock Selection

June 11, 2024

We have gained a number of new investors and get regular vetting interest from investors who need to understand the roots of our stock-picking discipline. Our stock-picking discipline is built around our eight...

⟶ Keep Reading

We Advise Investors

Sign up to get our advice sent straight to your inbox.

US INVESTORS

Individual Investors

OR

Financial Advisors, Family Offices,
and Institutional Investors

OR

NON-US INVESTORS

Individual Investors

OR

Financial Advisors, Family Offices,
and Institutional Investors

OR

Scroll to Top