Value Investing: Business as Usual

Printable Version

Dear fellow investors,

At the age of 35, I’m almost thirteen years into my career in the investment business. I was lucky to get a job right out of college in the brokerage business before joining Smead Capital Management at our formation. For most millennials like myself the last ten years have formed what we believe the business to be: a bull market reinvigorated by the whims of the Federal Reserve Board. If anchoring is a powerful force in investor behavior, the anchor at the depths of our millennial beliefs is that value hasn’t worked. We’d like to contextualize value stocks underperforming to frame whether this is a fundamental problem or if other factors outside of value are deluging the underperformance.

GMO’s Rick Friedman in a piece titled “Value Investing: Bruised by 1000 Cuts,” brought this conversation to a head by presenting the discount of value stocks to the average stocks in the chart below. As readers can see, based on their data we are in the 92nd percentile of value’s cheapness relative to the average stock in the U.S. It’s discount as of the end of February 2019 was 31% to the average stock. This compares to their historical average of 24%.

In the piece, Friedman goes on to say:

We believe that value will continue to exhibit the same characteristics it has historically: lower growth, higher yield, and positive return from multiple expansion and rebalancing. After losing 1% per year over the last 12 years as value stocks cheapened relative to the market, they are currently trading at abnormally wide discounts that should provide helpful tailwinds going forward. The increasing cheapness of value will reach a limit at some point. Given value’s relative growth has not deteriorated, we do not see any fundamental reason value stocks deserve to trade cheaper than they normally have. Even if the relative cheapness of value does not revert but simply stops widening, value stocks should outperform thanks to its other drivers of return. From a cyclical perspective, value globally is priced to win.

To follow on this, we came across a prescient piece by JPMorgan’s research team titled “The Value Conundrum.” Their note broke out examples of inverse relationships that value has exhibited in the last 12 years. Below is a chart that shows how the relationship has been true using forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios.

This is the only cycle that has rewarded the forward P/E ratios of the most expensive stocks and provided little or no benefit to the cheapest.

While this seems extreme, the old adage is that the market can stay irrational longer that you can stay solvent. Is the market’s irrationality based on the value factor or are other factors muddying the water?

In our CIO Bill Smead’s piece “The Risk Pendulum,” we highlighted how the volatility of stocks is playing a major role in this. Below is another illustration. The cheapest stocks have exhibited the highest beta, while the most expensive stocks have exhibited the lowest beta.


Source: JPMorgan

They say don’t confuse brains with a bull market. Based on this great work, we’d say don’t confuse near-term stock price movements as a forecast of the future. As Charlie Munger said at the 1995 Berkshire Hathaway Shareholder meeting, “People don’t seem to care what floor they’re at, just whether the elevator is going up or down.” Yes, value has underperformed the last 12 years. Yes, lower volatility stocks have done great the last 12 years. Yes, younger generations of investors are completely anchored by this.

In our opinion, there is not much that needs to go right over the next five years. If the discount of value stocks to the average stock in the market just holds its current levels, value should outperform. If volatility picks up for all stocks, that would be more painful for the lower volatility stocks. For value investors, the volatility would just be business as usual.

Warm regards,

Cole Smead, CFA

The information contained in this missive represents Smead Capital Management’s opinions, and should not be construed as personalized or individualized investment advice and are subject to change. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Cole Smead, CFA, Managing Director and Portfolio Manager, wrote this article. It should not be assumed that investing in any securities mentioned above will or will not be profitable. Portfolio composition is subject to change at any time and references to specific securities, industries and sectors in this letter are not recommendations to purchase or sell any particular security. Current and future portfolio holdings are subject to risk. In preparing this document, SCM has relied upon and assumed, without independent verification, the accuracy and completeness of all information available from public sources. A list of all recommendations made by Smead Capital Management within the past twelve-month period is available upon request.

©2019 Smead Capital Management, Inc. All rights reserved.

This Missive and others are available at www.smeadcap.com.

We Advise Investors

Sign up to get our advice sent straight to your inbox.

Recent Missives

The Mayor White Problem for Investors

August 9, 2022

[...] Ideological thinking has run amok in the allocation of capital. This has transpired from government edicts and will, a typical creator of a bubble. It is promoted by the promoters, who are...

⟶ Keep Reading

Bear Markets Like This One

July 26, 2022

We are getting questioned constantly on how long this bear market in U.S. stocks will continue. It’s a reasonable question, and as we always do, we look back at the most similar situations...

⟶ Keep Reading

2Q22 International Value Strategy Newsletter: The Rhythm of the Night

July 15, 2022

Corona’s 1995 classic “The Rhythm of the Night” rings in our ears as we stare at the circumstances that are likely to expose the darkness of the 2020’s. We saw the light in...

⟶ Keep Reading

2Q22 U.S. Value Strategy Newsletter: Two-Headed Investment Monster

July 15, 2022

As we’ve hit the halftime mark for the investment year 2022, we are faced with a daunting two-headed monster. One head is the first full year of unwinding what Charlie Munger called, “the...

⟶ Keep Reading

Love is in the Air

July 6, 2022

[...] Chairman and largest shareholder, Harold Hamm, is trying to own our shares of Continental Resources (CLR US) at a price of $70. We’ve seen it trade above there in the open market...

⟶ Keep Reading

Buffett, Jones and Hamm: An Oil Wisdom Trifecta

June 28, 2022

Someone once said, “Better than being smart is knowing who is!” Over the last few weeks, three of the richest and most successful businessmen in the U.S. have let us know what they...

⟶ Keep Reading

We Advise Investors

Sign up to get our advice sent straight to your inbox.

US INVESTORS

Individual Investors

OR

Financial Advisors, Family Offices,
and Institutional Investors

OR

NON-US INVESTORS

Individual Investors

OR

Financial Advisors, Family Offices,
and Institutional Investors

OR

Scroll to Top